Since it’s my birthday today (at least for 25 more minutes as I write this), I went to see Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. I really enjoyed it, and it generated a blog post idea — Which Orlando Bloom do you like better:

as Legolas in the Lord of the Rings trilogy or…

as Will Turner in the Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy?

Though I love the Legolas character, I’m going to have to go with Will Turner. He’s heroic, will do anything for his lady love, and he looks good while doing it. While Captain Jack Sparrow is very funny, I love the Will Turner character.

19 Responses to “Which Orlando Bloom?”
  1. Marianne Arkins says:

    I thought he was HOT in LOTR… and then I saw this most recent Pirates and, oh yeah, he’s got it going on.

    I wouldn’t kick either of them out of bed for eating crackers, but if I had to choose, it’d be Will Turner.

    Yum.

  2. MaryF says:

    What a great picture!!!

    HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!!

  3. Trish Milburn says:

    I know, isn’t that a HOT picture? Thanks on the birthday wishes.

    Marianne, LOL on the crackers in bed comment. :)

  4. TJBrown says:

    Will Turner. Yup. Except he kind of makes me feel like a dirty old woman. LOL
    Teri

    (my good news is on my blog if you want to check it out:)

  5. jo lewis-robertson says:

    Oh my gosh, between the devil and the deep blue sea. Love them both, but I have to go with the mysterious air of Legaolos. jo

  6. Beth says:

    Will Turner. I’m partial to guys with dark hair — although he looked mighty pretty as a blonde too ;-)

  7. Anna Campbell says:

    Nah, Legolas all the way. Although poor Orlando always seems to have such great competition. I mean, Aragorn in LOTR? Who could look anywhere else? Sigh. Captain Jack? How sexy can you get? Happy birthday for yesterday, Trish! May this be the year when your dreams come true.

  8. Natalie Damschroder says:

    Happy Birthday, Trish!

    It’s a tough choice. Legolas is so acrobatic and expressive. And just pretty.

    But I go for Will, who in this third movie is All. Grown. Up. And then some.

    Teri, Orlando is 30, so no worries about the dirty old woman thing. :)

  9. Kendra Clark says:

    Pirates…Drool…

  10. Kendra Clark says:

    Happy Birthday!

  11. Tawny says:

    Happy Birthday, Trish!!!

    and I vote for Will, baby :-) Legolas was hot, but not so much sexy.

    Will, though - whew!! Hot, sexy, strong… he definitely has it all going on. Especially in the third movie.

  12. Trish Milburn says:

    Thanks for all the birthday wishes. I’m loving the discussion on today’s topic. Keep the comments coming.

    P.S. I also liked Orlando in Elizabethtown. And I’ve been to the actual E-town many times.

  13. Caren Crane says:

    I choose Legolas! Having cut my young teeth on the LOTR series, I had a bad thing for Elves. Orlando as Legolas was such a gratifying personification of Legolas! Of course, he had a lot of gorgeous, blond, Elven brethren as well. Much more appealing to me than the manly, but very unhygienic Aragorn. (Y’all know that that Vigo didn’t bathe for weeks when filming that, right?)

    There was also quite a bit of dirt and grease in Pirates. Legolas was just so…clean.*g*

  14. Kirsten says:

    I haven’t seen POC3, so it’s hard to say, but to be honest (I hate to say it) neither really floats my boat. Can I have Aragorn instead? I mean, after he washes his hair? (g)

    Happy Birthday, a couple of days late!

    -Kirsten

  15. Trish Milburn says:

    Kirsten, sure, you can have Aragorn. More Orlando for me. :) And thanks on the b-day wishes.

  16. Jeanne (AKA The Duchesse) says:

    I go for Will. ;> I haven’t seen POC3 yet - sigh - but it’s a pirate’s….hmmm…for me! Heehee. Legolas is just too gender neutral in LOTR for me. :> But as someone else said, he has SUCH competition…Cap’n Jack. Yum. Aragorn. Yum. (And I agree about the hair washing.)
    Oh, and what a happy birthday present YOU got, going to the movies. Happy Birthday a day or so late.

  17. Button Fuzz says:

    Didn’t even realize they were the same person. Does he only do trilogies?

    Hubby

  18. Anonymous says:

    I like him as Will Turner because he doesn’t have fake blue eyes or fake blonde hair. He is the natural, talented sex symbol we love today. With his deep brown eyes and his beautiful, curly,brown hair he is hot in the Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy.

  19. Anonymous says:

    icecup413
    I am in love with his Will Turner character. In the LOTR trilogy he had fake blue eyes and fake blonde hair. He looks so mysterious and sexy in POTC. What with his sexy hipnotizing eyes and his playful brown curls he is the sexy,talented brit I love today, no contest

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security text shown in the picture. Click here to regenerate some new text.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word